Writing Excuses 21.46: Manifestations of Character Success
From https://writingexcuses.com/21-46-manifestations-of-character-success
Key Points: Success? Defining and delivery? External, MacGuffins, or avatars of success. Emotional success, moral failure. MacGuffins lack agency, while avatars represent change. Emotional resonance item.
[Season 21, Episode 46]
[Advertising]
[???] What does it look like to build a writing life you can sustain? To understand not only what stories you want to tell, but who you are as a writer, and how to keep putting your work out into the world? That's what we'll be exploring at the 2027 Writing Excuses Retreat, June 10th through 16th in Indianapolis, Indiana. We'll be partnering with Maurice Broaddus and the Ray Bradbury Center, around the theme of learning to love your work. That theme will guide our classes, workshops, and breakout sessions throughout the week. Learn from instructors Mary Robinette Kowal, Maurice Broaddus, and Jason Aukerman, with more instructors to be announced. Early bird pricing is available now for a limited time. And we're also welcoming scholarship applications. You can learn more at www.writingexcuses.com/retreats.
[End of advertising]
[Mary Robinette] This episode of Writing Excuses has been brought to you by our listeners, patrons, and friends. If you would like to learn how to support this podcast, visit www.patreon.com/writingexcuses.
[Season 21, Episode 46]
[Mary Robinette] This is Writing Excuses.
[DongWon] Manifestations of character success.
[Erin] Tools, not rules.
[Howard] For writers, by writers.
[Mary Robinette] I'm Mary Robinette.
[DongWon] I'm DongWon.
[Erin] I'm Erin.
[Howard] And I'm often wondering whether or not I succeeded. My name's Howard,
[Howard] And we talk a lot in business, in the business of the arts, how do you define when you've succeeded as a writer, as an artist, as a cartoonist? And sometimes the definition of success is are you still enjoying it? You're still able to get out of bed in the morning and sleep under a roof and eat healthy food? Success. That's... there you are. When we create characters in stories, we need to find ways to tell the reader, to communicate to the reader, whether or not those characters have succeeded at the goals they had or have overcome the trials that we as authors have set before them. And this is better if it's more than just yay, we blew up the Death Star. There needs to be something beyond that. I'm going to use an example from Schlock Mercenary. The book Delegates and Delegation opens with an argument between Sergeant Schlock and Captain Murtaugh, who is serving as captain over Schlock for the first time. And she calls him in and he says, yes, sir, and she says, that 's the wrong form of address, and he says, yes, ma'am, and she says, you're still not there, and he says, please, captain, just tell me what you want me to say, and she says, there it is. She wants him to call her captain, but that moment is not the manifestation of success. That moment is when we define what success is going to look at. And at the end of the book, when we've succeeded in stopping an enormous civil war and we've introduced a technology that is going to change the face of galactic culture, the true manifestation of success is Schlock saying something along the lines of, yeah, she's my captain, of course I'll do what what she wants. And that's the sort of thing that we as readers find satisfying. How do you go about defining and then delivering on success in your characters' arcs?
[Mary Robinette] So there is... there's a number of different ways. I find it very useful to have something that is an external manifestation. So in the first Spider-Verse film, there's this great rant that the alternate universe Peter Parker delivers about where's the dongle? Everything... There's always a dongle. Sometimes it's a whozzit, sometimes it's a whatchamacallit. It's a gadget. There's always something that the bad guy wants that we have to keep away from them. And that is in many ways when we're talking about a MacGuffin...
[DongWon] Yeah.
[Mary Robinette] Or an avatar of success, that's what we're talking about. It is a thing... it can be something that we set up, a success state that we know from the beginning. that when we get the briefcase, we will have succeeded. And so the hero's proximity to the briefcase measures how much success or failure they're experiencing in a given moment. Like, there's often the thing where they have it, and then it slips out of their grasp and the bad guys have it again. So that's one, which is a kind of a MacGuffin. And often the MacGuffin doesn't actually matter. It just represents success. It's like, yeah, we need the briefcase but...
[DongWon] This is the literal Maltese Falcon.
[Mary Robinette] Yes.
[DongWon] This is the briefcase from Pulp Fiction. This is...
[Mary Robinette] Exactly.
[Howard] Every other device from the Mission Impossible movies.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah. So an avatar is... serves a similar function, but it's often an incarnation or an embodiment of an idea. And so an example of this would be a thing where you're also invoking symmetry which we talked about in the last thing, which is, like, if your hero at the beginning is in the trenches of World War I and his feet are cold and wet, then at the end he's got warm dry socks. And that's.... it creates this symmetrical moment, but it's also the socks then become this avatar of success. It's like, ah, I'm now in a safe place. So often the avatar is not necessarily something that they have been pursuing, but it is a representation of an idea.
[DongWon] Well, sometimes, my issue with MacGuffins is they can feel hollow.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[DongWon] Right? Because... When Hitchcock coined the term, he really does explicitly talk about it as an empty signifier of a thing that is important to the characters, it is important for the plot, but the thing itself is not of deep relevance. When we look at fiction that falls more into a melodramatic space, which can be really useful because the delineation between, like, internal character motion and external action is, like, smooshed down. Superhero fiction's a great one to look at for that, right? And so going back to Spider-Verse again, this external manifestation of the suit is such a clear example of success, right? When Miles finally makes his own suit, makes his own design, expresses his internal conflict externally, that becomes a manifestation of that success, right? And so when the character sort of becomes their own avatar, I find that that can be really useful. I just played a really wonderful James Bond video game which is First Light and it's a prequel game where you're playing Bond very early on and it... the game does a fantastic job of communicating how you're not... you're not 007 yet, you're just this guy named James Bond, and they do it by giving and withholding iconic things. You get the Omega Seamaster watch early in the game and you're like, damn, I'm Bond now, I got this cool watch, but the Aston Martin with all the guns and the oil slick and all that, it's in the back of Q's lab. You can see it all the time, you can watch them testing it, and every time you get near it, they're like, don't touch that, you're not allowed to touch that. And so the way they withhold iconic things that make the character the character are a way to hold out that avatar of success until the very end of the game where you get to hop in the car and blow a lot of stuff up and you're like, hell, yeah, I'm James Bond now. And so I think those are very simple reductive ways of thinking about what these avatars of success are, but I think the socks is a great example, right? What are small things that your character can do to manifest that are that sort of melodramatic expression of an internal state that can be reflected in a way that your audience can see?
[Erin] I really like success that is actually failure. So I'm a big fan of the emotional success, moral failure type of thing. So, like, in the socks example, like, having a character fixate... I think it's interesting to have characters really get into a MacGuffin and not realize it's hollow...
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[Erin] And then they do actions to achieve it, but ultimately, while they succeed, like, they have the thing at the end, from the perspective of the reader, you're like, was it really... like, do... is the MacGuffin going to keep you warm at night kind of feeling? Like, I would write a story, maybe, where somebody was in the war and they were surrounded by violence and their feet were cold and at the end they stab and kill a man for his socks.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[DongWon] Yeah.
[Erin] So their feet are warm, but in fact they have become the thing that they did not... that actually caused them this pain at the beginning. And so in that way, like, not all success has to be, like, good, it could be bad, but it just is, but for the character, they're like, I feel like I succeeded, and it's up to the reader to decide, like, is that the kind of success that I want for you? Maybe not, but it is the kind of success that you at this moment want for yourself.
[Mary Robinette] Well, and I would argue that the stabbing is also an avatar.
[DongWon] Yeah.
[Mary Robinette] And we could say avatar of failure, but it's an avatar that represents this is the end of this storyline.
[Howard] I think it might be worth pointing out here that I'm... when, Erin, when you say successes that are actually failures, another way to say this is defining an endpoint for a character's arc, defining an arrival for that character arc, and maybe the reader will see it as success, maybe the reader will see it as failure, maybe they will see it as triumph, maybe they will see it as tragedy, but because of the character's relationship to the avatar, the MacGuffin, they will know that we've arrived.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah, and that's really I think one of the primary functions of an avatar is to externalize...
[DongWon] Yeah.
[Mary Robinette] An often internal state.
[Howard] Yeah, that was a great note to pause on for going to a break because we're...
[Howard] We talk about MacGuffins, we talk about avatars. Sometimes it can be difficult to tell the difference. I mentioned at the beginning of the episode, Schlock Mercenary Delegates and Delegation, there is a point in that book early on where Schlock loses his MacGuffin, quote unquote. The captain had called him in, because they are going into... they're going on a diplomatic mission into an area where they are not allowed to have weapons, and so she takes away his plasma cannon. And this is a thing that the sergeant hates, and long-time readers of the comic look at that and say, Oh, no, he doesn't have his toy anymore. Well, is getting it back part of his character arc? The answer is no, he doesn't actually get it back, but we have one of my favorite moments in that story, where towards the end, in order to rescue people, we have Schlock and the team riding hijacked scooters with garden implements, and he's got a chainsaw, and he's looking like a cavalry soldier. And it is both MacGuffin-ish, only we switched MacGuffins, we switched the one type of weapon for another type of weapon and it is also avatarish. Turns out I didn't need that thing. What I needed was a way to do the thing without having that in my hand.
[Erin] I'm just going to take one second because I think I've entered the Twilight Zone or the Spider-Verse. Can you remind me when you say... so MacGuffin I understand, object that represents... an object that is necessary to the plot, but avatar... I know we used it in a previous episode, but remind me how we use it because I feel like somehow it has lost all meaning in my brain.
[Mary Robinette] Oh, yeah.
[DongWon] Well, you see, it's when you can use all four elements at once.
[laughter]
[Erin] Nice. Nice.
[Mary Robinette] So usually an avatar... so a MacGuffin often has no agency. An avatar... and they are interchangeable, and there's overlap between them, which is part of why it's confusing. An avatar often represents the essence of the change and frequently has agency. So a MacGuffin is pretty much always an inanimate object. An avatar can be an action. So we used the example previously in Dirty Dancing of the lift that Baby does. So in many ways, Baby in that moment is the avatar of her own success, but the lift is that moment that represents Baby has come into her own as a dancer. R2-D2 is an interesting one because R2-D2 is both a MacGuffin and an avatar. R2-D2 is literally a briefcase.
[DongWon] He has the Death Star plans in him.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[DongWon] Yeah.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah. And we... but for much of the film, the heroes... Luke doesn't know that. But R2 also has agency and when R2 is injured or put in peril, we are worried about R2 specifically as a character. And so that... that's kind of... that 's why these lines between them are so blurry, because often you have something that is both.
[DongWon] I mean, what's so interesting about that example, and it shows how you can play with an avatar of success is R2 is an avatar of success and is a MacGuffin, right? He has the Death Star plans in him, but also he represents Luke's call to adventure and moving into a broader world. In the final act of that movie... I'm again spoiling a movie from last century... R2 gets shot to hell, right? R2 gets blown up in the final trench run, which means that Luke is on his own. Luke is truly on his own in the moment that he needs to take the shot. He hears Obi-Wan's voice of use the Force, but taking away all those external avatars of success and him learning to rely on himself is a way that you can use what has been, up until this point, the external signal, and then flip it and reverse it and realize that no, success has to be internal, right? And that's sort of where thematically Star Wars is coming down to is you will find that strength within yourself, not external to you.
[Howard] Yeah, if Luke had just, haha, I've got this, and successfully hit the target and blown up the Death Star, it wouldn't have been nearly as satisfying as having him learn to use the Force and tune in to this Jedi magic.
[Mary Robinette] It is removing the crutch, removing the...
[Howard] Yeah.
[DongWon] Exactly. Yeah.
[Mary Robinette] And so that's why I think these are all different words that people are trying to use to describe the same sort of idea. I could... before I learned avatar or I knew what a MacGuffin was, but before I learned avatar, I was calling it an emotional resonance item, which is something that causes resonance back to something previously. And I think that's one of the other perhaps differences when you're thinking about an avatar versus a MacGuffin is that a MacGuffin is often present all the way through the book, and an avatar may be something that's more or less a callback.
[DongWon] Well, what's nice about the emotional resonance item, as clunky as the phrase is, is... I'm very critical of the advice show don't tell. I think it's way over-applied, but you can't always sit there the whole time and explain this is the character's relationship to an object. This is how they think about their past or whatever it is. The object can externalize that internal emotion, right? And I keep coming back to the term of melodrama here because I think it's really useful in this case, because it allows the action of a scene, it allows a physical object that a character has or carries or looks for or desires. And again, that can be a person. That can be a mother's relationship to their child. That can be somebody's relationship to their best friend or whatever it is. That avatar, which is I think why we're using this word, becomes embodied with a lot of meaning that the character is feeling internally. And it's a way for you to kind of use that almost as a repetitive motif throughout the story to be like, hey, remember that this character has a lot of feelings about their childhood. This object is connected to their childhood.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah, like in Pacific Rim, the little red baby shoes.
[DongWon] Yes.
[Mary Robinette] Which are this constant reference back to childhood and your understanding of them changes through the film as the character's own understanding of her emotional state changes as well.
[DongWon] And him returning the shoes to her is, in a way, him saying, I am relinquishing my father role here.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[DongWon] You are capable of making your own decisions. I'm going to stop making decisions for you. And therefore it becomes an avatar of her success as she becomes fully authorized to make her own choices, which is to get in a giant robot and punch in it... punch monsters with love. So, yeah.
[laughter]
[Howard] Punch monsters with love. One of the sentences that's stuck with me for a long time is you are what you do. The idea that our objectives as humans sometimes, I want to do a thing, but in our hearts of hearts, we want to be something more or better or kinder or stronger or happier than what we currently be. And for characters on the page, you can define that by just telling... and he had become the man he always wanted to be. But the avatar is a tool that lets you show what they are going to do that defines for us that they are now at that moment of being. And so one of the things that I find is really useful is to ask at the beginning of the book, what does this character want to be? What are the things that that character is going to do that will tell the reader that they have become that? And I don't use the term avatar in my outlining, but I'm using the concept of avatar absolutely as I go.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah, and I think this is something that we also see for ourselves in real life as well, that the number of writers that I know who have sold things and... but they don't... it doesn't kind of click for them until they're holding a physical copy in their hand, or they go into the library and it's like, oh, that's the moment, when they have this emotional connection to the truth of their journey, when they've been a writer all along.
[Erin] Yeah, I think... I also think about, like, how characters want to feel. I think that we are often character-wise, maybe personally, driven by, like, the emotions we want in the world. And a lot of times what we want to be is partly about what we think being that will make us feel. Sometimes we know because it's something we already have been or done, but sometimes we don't. And so it's like, I want to feel this way. I believe I will feel this way by being this way. Therefore, I will do these things to accomplish it. And again, like, I really like the tension between those, like, what if it turns out that being this doesn't make you feel this way, then what do you do...
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[Erin] In order to, like, deal with that? And so I think it'd be interesting to think about if you succeed in some... if you succeed on one of those levels, but not the other two, like, how does that change your relationship to an object or an avatar that represents that? Do you feel distanced from it? Do you no longer want the thing that you thought you wanted? Is there an object that you thought was going to be so meaningful to you and you get it and it feels hollow and it's a way to indicate that this did not have the resonance that I thought that it was going to have as a character because, for whatever reason, it just didn't get me... I became this thing to impress my parents is like a very well-worn trope, and then, like, they didn't care, and so it's like, I finally became a doctor, mom, and mom's like, whatevs. And it's like that way and therefore I don't care as much about the fact that I'm wearing the stethoscope around my neck.
[Howard] And I think an excellent example of that is Captain America the First Avenger. He wants to enlist. He wants to serve and he gets the super serum and ends up as a showpiece. He's serving, but we're only halfway into the movie. He got what he wanted, but he's not happy. He's not fulfilled. He needs something more than what he got, and that's why we have a whole second half of the film.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah. A lot of times we... I've talked about this in other episodes as objective superobjective, and that the objective is often this avatar, this external thing, that Erin is talking about, but when you get it, it does not in fact meet the criteria to fulfill the super objective.
[Howard] Well, I have some homework for you. I want you to create some uh some avatars to choose from for your character. Figure out what it is that this character wants or needs, whether or not they're correct in what they want, what they think they want or need. And then make a list of the things that will communicate to the reader that they have reached that point. As part of this, write down some things that the character thinks they need to do to have achieved that objective and include in that list some things that are incorrect. Some things that will actually land them in the wrong place.
[Mary Robinette] This has been Writing Excuses. You're out of excuses. Now go write.